On the surface, it looked like a win.

We were running four different lead magnets for a client—each designed to attract their ideal audience and move them into a nurture sequence.

And one of them?

Was blowing the others out of the water.

It had the lowest cost per lead (CPL) by far.

Naturally, it felt like the obvious winner.

But when we looked a little deeper, the numbers told a different story.

Cost Per Lead Is Not the Final Score

In fact, it can be misleading—dangerously so—if you don’t zoom out.

Because what happened next is something every marketer (and business owner) should pay attention to.

The lead magnet with the highest CPL?

The one that looked, at first glance, like the worst performer?

It had the lowest cost per conversion.

Meaning it brought in people who didn’t just download something and disappear—

They took action.

They converted.

They bought.

They stuck around.

Cheap Leads ≠ Profitable Leads

This is where a lot of marketing strategies get derailed.

It’s tempting to double down on the cheapest leads and call it a day.

But leads that don’t convert are just numbers.

What you want—what actually grows your business—is conversion-ready prospects.

And sometimes, those leads cost a bit more to acquire… but are far more valuable in the long run.

Don’t Stop at CPL—Dig Deeper

Here’s the real takeaway:

Cost per lead is only part of the story.

It’s a helpful indicator—but it’s not the whole picture.

To really understand if a campaign is performing, you need to look beyond the initial sign-up and ask:

• What happened after someone entered the funnel?
  
• Did they engage with follow-up emails?
  
• Did they book a call?
  
• Did they convert into a customer—or better yet, a long-term client?
  

Sometimes, the lead that cost a bit more to acquire turns out to be the one that delivers real value.

That’s why surface-level metrics can be misleading.

The real insights—the ones that drive profitable decisions—come from digging into what happens next.

So don’t just chase the cheapest leads. Chase the ones that convert.

And always take the time to explore what your data is really telling you.

Need a hand with your Facebook Ads? Here’s some options:

Done For You – Discover how we can take over all of your Facebook Ads hands-free.

Done With You – Explore the ways we can work alongside you and your marketing team.

Free Video Training – Instant access Facebook Ads training.

Free Resources – Handy guides and downloadables.

Blogs – More blog posts like this with real stories of strategy and success.